~ ~ ~
Introduction:
1. This section provides two simple illustrations to help people understand the Catholic Dogma on Automatic Excommunication for heresy (lying against the faith).
2. Below are comparisions of the "math teacher" who doesn't teach math ... and the "physics teacher" who doesn't teach physics ... with the vatican-2 cult group leaders (who are dressed like priests and bishops and in buildings with Catholic signs out front) who reject the Catholic Faith.
3. For the sake of this section ... set aside the fact that there are no bishops or priests in these times, as is proven on Section 13.6 of this site.
4. The analogy is not perfect ... in that the fictional persons described below may be just bad math or physics teachers ... so assume for the sake of this section these fictional teachers are always wrong. The other reason the analogy is not perfect is because ... if a Catholic is wrong (in heresy) on just one point of the Faith, he/she is automatically excommunicated.
Math teacher ... Example:
Given information 1: There is a person who claims to be a math teacher.
Given information 2: The person claiming to be a math teacher ... is in a math classroom of a school building.
Given information 3: The school's list of teachers ... lists him as a math teacher.
The teacher of the above given information proceeds ...
On the first day of school ... to walk into the classroom and teach the following: 2 + 2 = 5
On the second day of school ... to walk into the classroom and teach the following: 7 - 3 = 2
On the third day of school ... to walk into the classroom and teach the following: 8 x 3 = 20
On the fourth day of school... a student addresses the teacher and says ...
"Teacher, I checked the math book and it says: 2 + 2 = 4 ... not: 2 + 2 = 5."
"Teacher, the math book also says: 7 - 3 = 4 ... not: 7 - 3 = 2."
"Teacher, the math book also says: 8 x 3 = 24 ... not: 8 x 3 = 20."
The "teacher" immediately escorts the student out of the class and tells him not to come back, so that the truth about math doesn't get out.
... And he continues day after day ... to lie about math.
- - - -
Here are the two questions relevant to the comparison of this scenario ... with the Automatic Excommunication Dogma of the Catholic Church ...
Question 1: Is the person described above a math teacher?
Answer: No, of course not.
Question 2: Does there need to be a process, run by the school principle or school board ... to establish the fact that the subject person is not a math teacher ?
Answer: No, no process is needed to identify that the person is not a math teacher ... it is automatically established.
- - - -
The situation is identical ... with the Catholic Automatic Excommunication Dogma ...
The vatican-2 cult heretic ... who is dressed like a priest or bishop, working out of a building with a Catholic sign out front ... says that (other) heretics such as "lutherans", "baptists", "evangelicals", etc. are getting to Heaven and that they are Christians.
Question 1: Is the person a Catholic priest or bishop ?
Answer: No he's not ... because heretics are not getting to Heaven and they are not Christians.
Question 2: Is an administrative process required to determine and define that he is not a priest or bishop ?
Answer: No, no process is required ... the person is automatically not a priest or bishop.
Question 3: Are the persons who try to communicate the Catholic Dogma ... that heretics are headed for Hell and they are not Christians ... escorted off the of vatican-2 cult controlled properties (with the Catholic signs) and told not to return ?
Answer: Yes they are.
Physics teacher ... Example:
Given information 1: There is a person who claims to be a physics teacher
Given information 2: The person claiming to be a physics teacher ... is in a physics classroom of a school building
Given information 3: The school's list of teachers ... lists him as a physics teacher.
Given information 4: F=ma (Force = Mass times Acceleration)
Given information 5: P=vi (Power = Voltage times Current)
The teacher of the above given information proceeds ...
On the first day of school ... to walk into the classroom and teach the following: Force = Mass times Velocity ... "F=mv"
On the second day of school ... to walk into the classroom and teach the following: Power = Voltage times Resistance ... "P=vr"
On the third day of school... a student addresses the teacher and says ...
"Teacher, I checked the physics book and it says: Force = Mass times Acceleration (F=ma) ... not: F=mv."
"Teacher, the physics book also says: Power = Voltage times Current (P=vi) ... not: P=vr."
The teacher immediately escorts the student out of the class and tells him not to come back, so that the truth about physics does not get out.
... And continues day after day ... to lie about physics.
- - - -
Here are the two questions relevant to the comparison of this scenario ... with the Automatic Excommunication Dogma of the Catholic Church ...
Question 1: Is the person described above a physics teacher ?
Answer: No, of course not.
Question 2: Does there need to be a process, run by the school principle or school board ... to establish the fact that the subject person is not a physics teacher ?
Answer: No, no process is needed to identify that the person is not a physics teacher ... it is automatically established.
- - - -
The situation is identical ... with the Catholic Automatic Excommunication Dogma ...
The vatican-2 cult heretic ... who is dressed like a priest or bishop, working out of a building with a Catholic sign out front ... says that un-baptized pagans ("jews", "muslims", "buddhists", "hindus", etc.) and heretics ("lutheran", "vatican-2", "methodist", "evangelical", etc.) ... are getting to Heaven.
Question 1: Is the person a Catholic priest or bishop ?
Answer: No he's not ... there is not a single pagan or heretic in Heaven and there never will be.
Question 2: Is an administrative process required to determine and define that he is not a priest or bishop ?
Answer: No, no process is required ... the person is automatically not a priest or bishop.
Question 3: Are the persons who try to communicate the Catholic Dogma ... that you must be baptized in water to get to Heaven ... escorted off the of vatican-2 cult controlled properties (with the Catholic signs) and told not to return ?
Answer: Yes they are.
Summary
1. Clearly the fictional teachers of this section ... would be removed from the classroom by the school administrators for serially lying about their subject matter.
2. It's the same with the Catholic Church, in the Church's Dogma ... the person who is believing, writing, or speaking heresy against the Faith ... has their soul automatically removed from the Catholic Church ... even though their body may be in Catholic buildings (in prior times when the Catholic Church had physical properties) ... just like the body of the lying "math teacher" is in the math classroom.
Pope Leo XIII, Satis Cognitum, 29 June 1896, Para 9 >
"The practice of the Church has always been the same, as is shown by the unanimous teaching of the Fathers, who were wont to hold as outside Catholic communion, and alien to the Church, whoever would recede in the least degree from any point of doctrine proposed by her authoritative Magisterium."
Saint Thomas Aquinas, Doctor of the Church, died 1274 A.D. >
"Our faith is identical with that of the ancients. Deny this, and you dissolve the unity of the Church. We must hold this for certain: that the faith of the people at the present day is one with the faith of the people of past centuries. Were this not true, then we would be in a different church than they and, literally, the Church would not be One."
Catholic writing of Titus 3:10-11 >
"A man that is a heretic, after the first and second admonition, avoid: Knowing that he ... is subverted, and sinneth, being condemned by his own judgment."
~ ~ ~ ~
<<< --- <<< --- <<<
--- <<< --- End Section 13.2.1 --- >>> ---
>>> --- >>> --- >>>
Immaculate Heart of Mary ~ Our Lady of Good Remedy ~ Our Lady of La Salette ~
Immaculate Heart of Mary